Traditional recipes

This Tomato Slicing Test Will Tell You How Sharp or Dull Your Knife Is

This Tomato Slicing Test Will Tell You How Sharp or Dull Your Knife Is

We are searching data for your request:

Forums and discussions:
Manuals and reference books:
Data from registers:
Wait the end of the search in all databases.
Upon completion, a link will appear to access the found materials.

It’s the easiest way to know if you have the sharpest tools in your arsenal or it’s time for a tune up.

Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.

Many things need maintenance in your life – cars, pets, even your own health. But there’s probably one thing in your kitchen that you don’t ever think needs a check up here and there, and that’s your go-to knife.

Slicing and dicing ingredients on a daily basis is no easy feat for you, let alone the selection of knifes that are doing the dirty work every day. And there are many ways that your knife can suddenly become duller than you’d ever think it could – whether you put your knifes through the dishwasher, leave them in a pile in a kitchen drawer where they scratch and ding one another, or use a glass cutting board.

Eating healthy should still be delicious.

Sign up for our daily newsletter for more great articles and tasty, healthy recipes.

Don’t think you should care too much whether or not your blades are dull? Think again.

Dull knifes can be the prime reason for many kitchen accidents when it comes to your own home: if you need to exert additional and unnecessary force to slice through ingredients, there’s a greater chance of having that blade slip and forcefully move into another unwanted direction. Why make 15 tough cuts for something that normally only requires one or two slices?

How can you tell if your blade is in need of some sharpening?

There’s actually quite a few methods of home-testing this: cutting through printer paper, glossy magazine paper, slicing the cover off a printed magazine or booklet, or even trying to give your arm hairs a trim.

We definitely don’t recommend running a blade along your arm (nor do we ever want you to use Cooking Light pages as a test for your knife!), so we have another solution.

There’s a simple test to figuring out whether or not it’s time for you to invest in a honing steel, which is a handy tool that can help correct any mistreatment of your knife and bring the blade back to quality sharpness.

It’s known as the tomato test, and it’s something you probably try out more than once a week:

1) Place a beefsteak tomato on a cutting board with the stem facing up.

2) Balance your knife on the top of the tomato without applying any pressure.

3) Pull the knife back towards you and do not press down.

If your blade penetrates the skin of the tomato, you have a sharp knife and should rejoice. But don’t fret if the knife fails to make anything but a dent in your tomato – the honing steel is a great way to give second life to your favorite knife.

How To Sharpen Your Kitchen Knives

On your way to becoming a better cook, there are a few skills you must learn that go beyond actual cooking. One such skill is learning how to sharpen your kitchen knives.

This may not seem like a priority, but it is. First of all, sharp kitchen knives are a lot safer to use than dull knives. Keeping your knives sharp will also save you time when preparing meals and ensure that your food will cook properly.

Part of the process of learning how to sharpen your knives is understanding how they’re made. This will help you choose the right sharpening tool for the job. Let’s get started.

Quick Navigation

  • A very sharp knife – Never use a dull knife because you’re more likely to have an accident with a dull knife than with one that is nicely sharpened.
  • A fridge or freezer – The reason for this will become obvious in just a moment.
  • A metal tray and freezer bag(s) – Another thing that will become clear after you read further.
  • Meat – This is pretty self-explanatory, really, hopefully.
  • Delicious recipe – What else will you be doing with the meat once it has been cut?

Obviously, there are meat slicers that can do the trick. When you are shopping for the meat, you can ask the person manning the meat section to slice it for you. Unfortunately, fewer groceries or supermarkets seem to offer this service, or there is nobody available when you need them. However, if you don’t own a meat slicer machine and one prefers very thinly sliced beef, then it is not too difficult to do it by hand.

There is also an option to buy an already sliced product. However, the sizes and thickness may vary. Chefs would recommend that cooks do the slicing themselves to ensure uniformity and to be able to follow the instructions provided by the cookbook or recipe.

However, not everyone can slice the meat well as they do not have the proper tool—the meat knife. If one intends to slice meat in various shapes and sizes, then it is best to search the market and invest in a meat knife.

A Properly Sharpened Knife is More Important Than a Razor Sharp Knife

A good way to test whether your knife is properly sharpened is to do a paper slice in the air. Hold a piece of paper up in front of you and slice through the edge of the paper, starting with the back of the blade and slicing through to the tip. If the knife does not easily slice the paper, it probably is not sharp enough. If it slices through and then gets hung up at any point and begins to tear rather than cleanly cut the paper, you have discovered a problematic area on the edge. I like to use colored paper for this purpose, as it will leave little bits of paper on the part of the blade that needs work, and if the paper is colored these bits are easier to see.

There is no real point in having a razor-thin edge on your chef knife. Such an edge will simply be harder to keep sharp as the very thin edge will take damage easier or, depending on the metal, roll over quite easily. Sharp enough is sharp enough. I know there are many sharpening articles and YouTube videos which focus on getting your knife to a razor edge, but this seems to be designed to get traffic and to satisfy an unfounded need for perfection that, in the end, is overkill. I also think this zeal for razor sharpness is sometimes meant to make knife sharpening seem unapproachable. But, really, you’re not going to shave with your kitchen knife, are you? I can make extremely thin slices of tomato with my chef knife which is sharpened on a whetstone like this 1000/6000 Grit Whetstone from Home Pro Shop, even though the knife is probably not as sharp as a razor. And I am not an expert sharpener, I’ll readily admit.

This article contains one or more Amazon affiliate links. See full disclosure.

Stay Sharp with the Best Chef Knives

Almost every recipe starts with your ingredients and an invaluable tool: a chef's knife. Ask any professional chef or home cook, and they'll tell you that a good sharp knife is one of the most important kitchen utensils. But sharpness isn't the only thing you'll want to look for when shopping for chef knives. Knife shopping can actually be a pretty personal thing — it's a tool you'll use just about every day in the kitchen — so it's important to look for features that make it comfortable to use and able to handle all the recipes in your repertoire.

Think about comfort first. If you do plenty of chopping, mincing and dicing, you'll want a knife with an ergonomic handle that doesn't make your hand cramped and fatigued. Length is equally important — 8 inches is ideal for most people (and most cutting tasks), but it's best to size down an inch or two if you have smaller hands. What you cook is important to consider, too heavier, thicker steel knives are best (and the most durable option) if you cook meat often and might encounter bones. And carbon knives stay sharper longer, which is convenient if you don't mind carefully cleaning them.

Ready to shop for this fundamental kitchen tool? These are 10 of the top options to suit a variety of needs.

Now, on to the scary part: Sharpening the knife

Hold the knife at a 10 to 15 degree angle, with the blade facing away from your body and push the full length of the blade away from your body, along the stone at a diagonal. At the end of that stroke, gently turn the knife over and repeat, always stroking away from your body at a diagonal across the stone. Start with the coarse side of the whetstone, and then do a few rounds on the finer side. If needed, wipe your knife with a cloth to remove any debris.

Do dishwashers really blunt knives

I'm told I should not put sharp knives in the dishwasher because it will blunt them.

What is the mechanism by which this happens or is it a myth?

Re: Do dishwashers really blunt knives

I have had a 9" Sabatier knife for just over 20 years.

It's been sharpened with a steel whenever it needed it (every few uses) - the steel is now worn out, but the knife *blade* is fine.

However, the overall structure of the knife is a stainless steel blade & tang. It's an encapsulated tang though - the knife tang and end of the blade is wrapped in an aluminium sheath, and that's then inside the black plastic handle.

Because the encapsulating material is aluminimum, the highly caustic dishwasher tablets have eroded it, which means the blade is now slightly loose in the handle.

Since I realised this was happening, I've stopped putting it in the dishwasher, but the damage is done.

Re: Do dishwashers really blunt knives

However, the dishwasher powder might, since it contains highly alkaline compounds like trisodium phosphate, unless that powder also contains a corrosion inhibitor like sodium silicate.

Although "inhibiting" is not quite the same as "preventing", and so persistent long-term exposure to these chemicals will eventually degrade the materials, including dulling the edge (although that's the least of your concerns, since the rest of the knife is also deteriorating).

This is why professional chefs never put their expensive knives into the dishwasher (indeed they typically don't even trust them to the kitchen porter, but clean them personally).

Re: Do dishwashers really blunt knives

They get dull because the average person tosses them in the silverware basket with everything else - and it gets beat to death during agitation by the other utensils.

Re: Do dishwashers really blunt knives

I'm told I should not put sharp knives in the dishwasher because it will blunt them.

Well.. If your technique is poor then striking bone is a real posability.

There is no such thing as a sharp knife. Only a knife which has been sharpened well.

You should re-hone your edge prior to every use (within reason) store the knife well (I use a straw stabby-style knife holder, but magnetic ones are also good.

The edge can be diminished in a dishwasher due to the copious chemical and especially the sodium content, but seriously, if your knife-ware is of such poor quality that it is substantially impacted by this, then you have bought some really criminally poor shit, or you are washing it 12 hours a day every day.

Get a half decent knife sharpener (

The real questions in the kitchen are to do with quality (or otherwise) pans in the dishwasher. Do some research on Teflon & PFOA. Nice to have, but better to learn to cook properly )

Thursday 31st October 2013 23:01 GMT Fred Flintstone

Get a half decent knife sharpener (

Sorry, no. Those half-decent are actually rubbish, because you end up cutting with burrs rather than a honed edge. A standard steel is the best to keep the blade inline and in condition, provided you do it regularly and you use a knife of decent quality steel.

Um, sorry, no

If you want to keep them actually sharp you're stuck with traditional methods, although carborandum stones are no longer necessary (there are diamond stones for the rough-cut start) progressing up to and through the standard oil stone.

Steels are maintenance, they don't sharpen terribly well. That's why butchers hire people to sharpen their knives past a certain point.

And yes, cooking knives in dishwashers tend to be able to bang against other metal objects, resulting in nicks and eventual loss of the edge

So if I store the knives well and sharpen regularly I don't need to hand wash them?

Careful there

you're getting some potentially really bad advice above.

If you knives are stainless steel, dishwasher use may be ok-- in fact, many restaurant grade knives are designed for this. However, some of the best blades are high carbon steel (much sharper). You don't want any water sitting on carbon steel (rusting) and it tends to be more sensitive to chemicals.

Also, would recommend you be careful about sharpening. You don't want to actually do this often, you want to steel your blade at every use and sharpen as needed. Sharpening is a really good way to permanently destroy a blade if you don't know what you're doing and there are lots of cheap and not so cheap sets that will help you with that. In particular, most of the sharpeners that have two carbide bits (sometimes disks, sometimes rods) you pull your blade through and the electric sharpeners are recipes for destroying your edge. I've successfully used and would recommend the Lansky youtube demo here, but in general you shouldn't need to sharpen a lot and if you're about to buy a high-end knife, it should come from the factory with a pretty darn good edge. Read the manual for any sharpener you get carefully before you go and use it. Or, visit your local butcher and find out who they get to sharpen their knives. The key though, is a nice, long, steel (longer is easier to use and less work) with consistent, low pressure strokes.

Re: careful there

From my understanding, the alkali used in dishwasher "soap" causes decarburization (or decarbonization) at the knife edge, essentially leaving a rough surface. so not a rust issue, but a lack of sharp edge issue. I think some commercial dishwashers don't even use an alkali, rather high pressure water and steam, thus maybe in commercial world this is not an issue.

Re: careful there

In particular, most of the sharpeners that have two carbide bits (sometimes disks, sometimes rods) you pull your blade through and the electric sharpeners are recipes for destroying your edge

Personally I think those things should be flat out banned because they're dangerous. You end up with an edge which consists mainly of burrs. Sure, it'll cut really well afterwards - maybe twice if you're lucky - but you have just made an incredible mess.

Concur 100% with the steel observation - there is no substitute. You can follow up with a belt, but that's for perfectionists or cut throat razors :)

Hmm, whilst I have to agree with some of what HS said, I think that it all depends on the knife.

Prior to using the knife make a test cut, if that isn't clean, then sharpen the knife, this is just basic safety. I have used knives for butchery which have lasted years, being used 5 hours a day and sharpened sometimes twice a day+ especially when bones are involved.

The sharpener you use, if you aren't a knife geek is very important - butt there are plenty of simple ones on the market that do a great and safe job, you are honing, not grinding! A very important difference!

Regarding water / chemical corrosion. Slicing anything will get the knife wet and keep it wet. Slicing something like apples (especially) will pit the metal - high carbon metal very quickly. Many chefs I have talked to actually state that high carbon knives are not sanitary.

Bear in mind, of course, of all the equipment in the kitchen, the knife is amongst the easiest to wipe clean and store dry anyway!

As far as dulling the knife goes, storage and chopping board are just as important as washing.

I like this style of block: (though there are alo ones with none edge contact slots which are good)

I am happy using this style of sharpener:

I use Wusthof knives, I have a favourite knife for all prep work and this is this top one: - used extensively for many years and in the dishwasher at least 4 times a week probably.

But to answer your question, the mechanism by which this happens is oxidisation. The chemicals in the fruit / dishwasher / vegetables will do several things to increase the rate of corrosion. They help water be attracted to the metal (or rather they attract water full stop), and they help make the water a better conductor so the atoms in the oxidisation process can move more freely - this is a catch 22 style and obviously the most affected part will be the thinnest part, which is the edge.

good points. Ceramic (as used in the sharpener you suggest) is much less likely to screw up a blade than carbide. Personally not a fan of that style sharpener, but maybe because I've seen too many people mess up nice cutlery.

this is what I normally use-- takes and holds a great edge, unquestionably dishwasher friendly, and not at all expensive.

I have used Wusthof and Sabatier knives in other people's kitchens, but they've always been disappointingly dull in comparison to my $20 knife. Which goes to the general point of this discussion that you can have the most expensive and best equipment, but if you don't treat it right it won't perform.

It is indeed much more about what you do with it, rather than quality of your tools.

I worked in a catering shop that did a large range of knives (House of Knives in Petone) when I was at school, so got to see the people buying the full sets of forged Wusthof for looks, as well as lots of actual cooking professionals. Best way to sell someone was to let them chop up some carrots with a good example of each knife type, and let them decide. We also supplied the local catering college, and made sure they got good knives rather than the shit they get palmed off on some others.

Also lots of demonstrating steels and sharpening. Steels is nice and easy, you are drawing the blade across the lines in a smooth cutting motion at a 20 degree angle (roughly a quarter of a right angle) with firm but not hard pressure. The "safe" way is to put a steel vertical point down on a chopping board, and cut down it, so you should not cut anyone. A steel "realigns" the fine edge of the blade, pushing it back into alignment. Sharpening is cutting a new fine edge. You can steel your blade on pretty much any hardish metal, I've used the spine of other knives before in a pinch (and steel worktops, palette knives, pan lids etc)

As far as sharp knives go, proper butchers are the fussiest. It's the literal profit margin. But short of the cleaver and cooks knife, pretty much all butchery knives are flexible. Hence tend to be steeled often and sharpened more than any other knife.

For kitchen work, either a light, narrow high grade stamped steel blade or a more weighty forged blade will suit, depending on your budget and feel. Handle comfort is important. I've had professionals swear by each, the lighter blades need to be steeled or sharpened more often, but are less tiring and cheaper. If you need a single large cooks knife (over 10") then you mainly need the length as leverage, so a $30 Victorinex is as useful as a $400 for splitting pumpkins.

My biggest problem with Wusthof is they started making rolled steel stuff that looks like their forged stuff. I've spent a few thousand hours in kitchens using a Wusthof as my workhorse, with Victorinex for my paring knives.

My last work knife was a 9" Classic that was about 5mm thinner from repeated sharpening, and so the bottom inch or two worked as a cleaver (with a wider edge ground on it), and the rest as a normal knife. I won it in a poker game, and traded it away for bag of weed. That was a proper cooks knife :)

As for not being able to tell the difference, I've always been the one with all the kitchen kit in flats, and after the "knife talk" (I have plenty of normal ones, so the few that I'll get mad if you break I'll highlight, and the others can be wrecked) the flatties will use them. And have strong preferences for the Wusthofs. And when flats have moved on, and we run into each other, they always mention that they missed having sharp knives.

Going back to selling them to people, if they are both sharp, you'll notice the difference with a forged knife over a non forged one. Not one that by itself justifies paying 5-10x the price, but there is. If you can't tell the difference, then either they are blunt, or they are rolled steel Wusthofs. In which case, then there isn't any real difference, apart from the handles.

Dishwashers blunt knives when they get knocked against other things, as well as all the other noted parts. In general, knives need sharpening after a bit of use. At home, the wear on the edge from the dishwasher (assuming it gets washed after making dinner for 4) is probably as much as it gets from cutting things. All in all, probably going to have sweet FA effect on the blade. Handles, maybe a different story. Wood sucks for dishwashers, but is less problematic if ignited.

In terms of bang for your buck, a rolled stainless steel cooks knife (german, french or chinese) with a handle that fits your paw, ditto for a paring knife, is perfect. For a knife that will outlast you, forged ftw. I swore I'd never get a forged paring knife (frippery! It'll get thrown away with the peelings!) but got given one as a gift and use it for everything.

As for high carbon knives, I can't think of anyone who sells them for cookware, other than handmade stuff. You want harder, more brittle for cutting. And if you wanted flexibility, you just make a massively cheaper rolled steel. They have a use (easy to resharpen, hard to snap), but they rust like buggery.

TL, DR: Get Wusthof Classic or Grand Prix forged knives if you can afford it. All good rolled steel knifes are basically equal. Handles are important. Dishwasher safe knives are fine in dishwasher.

My beloved can and does destroy any blade by using carving knives to strip willow, etc. You try to cut anything in our kitchen and it makes no difference if you use the 'sharp' or blunt edge. She also objects if I attempt to re-grind them as they become 'too sharp and dangerous'.

The sharpest knife we have is actually a good quality stainless steel butter knife with a bone handle (which has become dyed pink, goodness only knows how) - somehow it has stood up to punishment the actual chopping, paring etc knives wilt at.

I am guessing that you have tried to argue that sharp knives are safer, because you know where they will go, use less pressure, etc.?

Although, don't try the argument that sharp knives are better because you won't feel it as much if you do cut yourself. That one does not fly.

She also objects if I attempt to re-grind them as they become 'too sharp and dangerous'.

If my wife said something like that she would get laughed at and told to think about what she's saying. We've had exchanges like that, going both ways, many times.

Knives are SUPPOSED to be sharp and dangerous. That's why you don't let little kids cut up their own steak. But as was mentioned above a very sharp blade is far less dangerous in the kitchen than a kinda sharp blade.

IMO a blunt knife is more dangerous than a sharp one. With a blunt knife you have to use more force and have less control. But I don't have kids to worry about.

I use a ceramic wheel sharpener with Global knives, the type you put a bit of water in and it works great.

I don't use a dishwasher on them, but when I wash them I NEVER let go of the handle, cos having that blade lurking hidden in the washing up would be stupid.

Oh I fully agree about blunt knives being waaaayyy more dangerous, but I also don't cut towards myself ffs. Pick your battles in this life, that's not one I'm going to win.

Thursday 31st October 2013 18:07 GMT Kubla Cant


My ex-wife puts knives in the dishwasher, and hers are always blunt. Mind you, they're crap knives to start with. The other problem is that the knife is always in the dishwasher when you need it.

I've never used a sharpener - the grinding noise as you drag the blade through it sounds too much like damage happening. For the past couple of years I've been using a ceramic "steel" , and I find it much more effective than the steel steel I used before. When I bought my insanely expensive Global knife, I couldn't persuade myself to get an £80 Global ceramic steel as well. I subsequently found a ceramic steel in Ikea, for £10 IIRC. Actually, the top-of-the-range knives I bought in Ikea are pretty good, too, and much cheaper than Global.

@Hungry Sean: "Sabatier" isn't a brand. It used to be a name used indiscriminately by manufacturers in Thiers , the French equivalent of Sheffield, but more recently it just describes any French-style cooking knife, typically with a triangular blade and a black handle.

Re: Ceramic

Never saw the point in Global. Looks cool, average steel quality, no bolster. Handle is OK in normal position, but lack of bolster means (for me anyway) when holding it with the blade in a pinch, the side of my middle finger is against a straight and rather uncomfortable edge. Hardly sold any either, but that's more just bad price point. You could get a forged one for the same price, or comparable one for a quarter of the price.

A steel is a steel. Cheap works just fine :)

Ceramic knives?

Can they go in the dishwasher?

Do they need to be re-sharpened by their manufacturer?

Thursday 31st October 2013 19:44 GMT Charlie Clark

Re: Ceramic knives?

Ceramic blades hardly ever get blunt but they are very brittle so it depends what use them for and especially what the chopping surface is like. If you chop quickly, say your slicing carrots, on a hard surface you'll quickly splinter it on a softer surface you'll get years of use.

If a ceramic knife does need sharpening you can do it with an electric device but much better to take it to a knife shop and let them do it.

Re: Ceramic knives?

A friend uses ceramic knives, and curiosity led me to check the edge with a jeweler's loupe. The wear process was chipping, with still-sharp bits between the chips. Looked to me as if it was turning itself into a serrated knive with a sharp, intermittent edge. I suspect it'll stay super sharp until most of the original edge is gone.

Can anyone who actually knows what they're talking about expand on this?

Note to webmaster: We really need an icon of someone talking through a hat.

I imagine the mechanism is people putting them in the same basket perhaps with other assorted utensils and the water jets simply jostle them all together. They then find the sharpened edge softened by tines, handles and whatnot.

Speaking for myself, I don't put my good knives in the dishwasher for two reasons. First I've had one cut through the plastic basket and get beat up by the spinning whirly-gig underneath and second was me being a bit careless when unloading, and having decided that blade up was better, that left a nice scar on my left index finger. Now I wash, dry and store the sharp knives individually to avoid both problems.


I've noticed corrosion on my V-Sabatier knives since my wife has been putting them in the dishwasher. I can't say if they are getting dulled by the process as she also sharpens them regularly with a grinder. I'm willing to believe stainless is more hygienic, but it won't hold as keen an edge as non-stainless. After sharpening with a pocket whetstone, my sailmaker's knife will cut through eight layers of flax sail cloth without much effort. I can't get the same edge on my rig knife, but then it has to deal with salt water.

Thursday 31st October 2013 19:53 GMT Charlie Clark

Re: corrosion

The dishwasher powder, and especially the softening salt, promote corrosion. How heavy the corrosion is will depend to some extent on the hardness of the water: harder water needs more softening and more softening will mean more corrosion. There are tabs that you can buy that are designed for use with steel and silver (even more susceptible to corrosion) that I find really* do make a difference and now I only use them when washing knifes or pans.

In general, however, knives are easiest washed by hand. If you do wash them in the dishwasher then use the special tabs, use the shortest, gentlest cycle and take them out and dry them as soon as the cycle has ended.

* I recently bought a pH-meter to help identify the best water filter for the very heavy calcium content in the water here, so I do take these things perhaps a little too seriously.

Re: corrosion

Since I managed to miss it in my spiel above, you are absolutely correct. High carbon needs more frequent sharpening, but can hold a finer (thus sharper) edge. It's softer, and will also take more abuse before snapping or cracking.

Even if you decide they are too unhygenic for the kitchen, they work great as hunting or butchering knives :)

It's a combination of factors. First and foremost there are corrosive chemicals in your dishwasher. They're not going to hurt most of your dishes, but the edge on a blade is surprisingly delicate (well, most blades anyway). Unless you've got a VERY good knife it's not going to be able to stand up to that. Second, people tend to throw all their silverware, knives included, in one basket. The rub up against each other as the dishwasher runs. Now considering that a glass cutting board can do some serious damage to your blade, imagine what a steel fork will do. Third, the blades don't get dried as quickly in the dishwasher as when they get hand washed. Water isn't good for steel. Even stainless steel can only take so much sitting around in water before it starts to feel the effect.

Having got myself into straight razor shaving you learn a lot about sharp edges and keeping them sharp. Stropping them on leather will get the edge back to normal. After a while you will need to sharpen using a sharpener though.

Even against your forearm! Try it! I haven't changed my blade in 5 years. Just run it down your forearm half a dozen time before you use it (wet) and voila - everlasting shaving blade. (long or mach 3 stylee)

Always wash the sharp blades by hand and individually.

Dishwashers use cleaning agents that has a grit like component which sandblast the dirt off as much as the detergent dissolving grease and they use a high pressure jet to do it. It's this which dulls the edge of the sharp knives more than the chemicals. Just check plates that have had a life of dishwasher cleaning, there are minute scourings which cut into the glaze which you don't get from hand washing and it also removes patterns/pictures from sand etched glasses.

I find that a diamond coated steel is the best way of keeping a good hone on my knives (as well as not letting others use them!) but you need to be able to keep a constant angle of blade to steel (about 17 degrees) or you are wasting your time. If the diamond-steel is new it cuts metal very fast and the inexperienced can ruin an edge in a couple of strokes but they OK for a regrind thus I always have two, one new and rough the other old and smooth which is used daily for the touch up.

Thursday 31st October 2013 19:36 GMT Will Godfrey


Can someone buy me a dishwasher so I can try this out for myself please?

I never knew what sharp was.

I never knew what sharp was until I got a Spyderco Sharpmaker set. The stones are excellent, and the base provides a very simple (upright is easy for eye to judge) means of getting the angle right. It takes most of the skill out of the job, but not all of it. It is fairly easy to sharpen a kitchen knife so it will shave arm hairs effortlessly --- but it still requires time, patience and some work. You can use the stones independently of the base to sharpen just about anything ---with as much skill as you can muster--- so this kit does not limit one.

Quick and easy version is my Chef'sChoice 2-stage hand sharpener. No shaving, at least not with my knives, but much much quicker to get to fine-slice-a-ripe-tomato stage. In other words: quick and useful! But also much more aggressive on the knives. I'd like an electric one, but that would be shere luxury for an occasional cook, even one who sharpens the knife almost every time. Chef'sChoice seem to be *the* choice of electric sharpener, unless one moves to workshop kit.

My knives are carbon steel. They get sharp more easily they get blunt quickly they stain, and rust if left wet. Do pro cooks still use these things? I doubt it. Stainless knives are so very much better these days than they were decades ago. If I were young, today, in my first home, it would probably be stainless all the way --- with a Chef'sChoice pro 3-stage electric sharpener which does honing and steeling as well as grinding.

But I still would probably not buy a dishwasher. Washing up is just not *that* much hassle. So I wouldn't be asking about putting my knives in one!

I prefer manual sharpening

But then I tend to use japanese style knives. I also clean them after use not put into a dishwasher. Only really need to resharpen every 6 months or so. But then my kitchen probably has more blades than any other utensils.

Can you keep the discussion focused, please?

Having debated this point with my brother for years (basically I think that dishwashers should do no harm and he does not get his knives even close to it), I came to this topic with high expectations of being able to finally settle the debate. Only to find a really long thread where people mostly expose their cutting preferences. Please, restrict yourselves to the point: is a knife safe in the dishwasher?

Sharp stuff from an engineers perspective on keeping it sharp

There's a lot of good advice and some bad above. That said knives (or any sharp thing) are like women, wine and beer, it's what works for you that really matters. Not what some knob at the cutlery store sold told you. How you use the sharp thing determines what 'sharp' is, as noted above, there's no such thing as 'sharp' just well done and task appropriate sharpening/honing.

Now for the Big Question: Does a dishwasher dull a blade? The answer is no. However, as others have noted, water/minerals/chemicals inside the dishwasher will have a negative impact on how cleanly you cut your (thing).

The sharp part of any sharp blade is made at the very, very, very edge of the blade and is defined by the angles at which the two sides of the knife intersect. The actual part that does the cutting can be seen under 20x magnification, but everything behind that intersection has no effect on the sharpness of the blade, only how the body of the blade interacts with the material as it follows the sharp edge (again, ideally the blade is purpose designed, ie: bread knife).

As the actual sharp part is very small, it is highly susceptible to mineral deposits and corrosion (even stainless and ceramic) that are not visible to the naked eye. Those deposits most certainly have a negative effect on sharpness but are somewhat intensified because they are carried and deposited as particulates in the steam inside a dishwasher instead of being carried away as they are under running water. The steam deposits a nice even coating of particulates across the entire edge.

Another factor is the 'wire edge' created during most abrasive sharpening processes. A stone or burnisher leaves a teeeeny little piece of metal (or ceramic) just past the actual intersection of the two sides of a blade. It is a function of the sharpening and can not be eliminated in process: Removing it is another step (below). Cheap knives are left with this edge intact intentionally, as it is very sharp but it breaks off easily, which is the leading reason cheap or poorly sharpened knives go dull quickly, this unsupported wire edge breaks off. The act of placing a knife in the dishwasher is almost perfect for breaking this edge off as well, but in this case it's the rack that's doing the damage, not the water itself.

In any case, putting water on knives, of any material, is the main issue and it is only intensified by the dishwasher, but the water itself is the problem.

Lastly, a well sharpened knife will stay that way for many decades of home use with 20 seconds on a leather strop after you sharpen it with a stone, a burnisher or cleaning it. Unless you drop it or stab someone hit something hard like a bone you don't need aggressive sharpening. All you are doing is removing excess material from the blade and repeatedly creating, and subsequently breaking off in use, a wire edge. A strop cleanly removes that wire edge (as opposed to breaking it off) and keeps the actual intersection of the sides even and clean (sharp). Even the finest diamond hones are too coarse at the microscopic level where a strop works. Additionally, it looks totally badass when you break out an old school strop before you cut into the sacrificial holiday animal and your knives will last exponentially longer. My cooking knives were made for my family by a New Hampshire blacksmith in 1784, they've seen sharpening stones exactly 13 times in all those years and they are unbelievably sharp, just from a good stropping after cleaning and before use. It only takes a few seconds.

Re: Sharp stuff from an engineers perspective on keeping it sharp

OK - you beat me. I'm happy that I have the knives that put my mum through chef school about 30 years ago. When she gave up cooking she passed them to me. I've had them since 2000.

And after that time they are still the sharpest I have ever used, with them being honed on the steel twice a year at most when my mum visits - she can do that far better than I can, and I really believe in knowing what you are good at, and what you should get someone else to do :)

As to topic, I have been told I can put them in a dishwasher by various people, but couldn't bring myself to do it! It's not like they take long to wash by hand (you just have to be careful)

Farberware Knives Review

1. Farberware Edgekeeper 21-Piece Forged Triple Riveted Block Set

  • 8-inch Chef Knife
  • 6-inch Chef Knife
  • 8-inch Slicer Knife
  • 8-inch Bread Knife
  • 7-inch Santoku Knife
  • 6-inch Cleaver
  • 6-inch Boning Knife
  • 5.5-inch Serrated Utility Knife
  • 3.5-inch Paring Knife
  • 3-inch Bird’s Beak Paring Knife
  • (8) Steak Knives,
  • Carving Fork,
  • One pair of Kitchen Shears
  • Storage Block
  • Rich and elegant design
  • Affordable set with a variety of knives
  • Durable high carbon stainless steel
  • Ergonomic handle with three rivets
  • Handles may break easily
  • Not a full tang
  • Santoku knife and Chef’s knife are not as sharp.

Finding a set of finely designed knives that perfectly cut the food items and not your pocket may feel like too much to ask for. Yet, that does not hold true with the Farberware set including 21-Piece Forged and Triple Riveted knives with an Edgekeeper Block. The blades are ultra-sharp from edge to the base making its agile movement seamless enough to pass through any food. Besides the knives, you are also offered a cherry finish woodblock that equips an EdgeKeeper built-in knife sharpener to hone the blades whenever the need appears. The set provides the owner with the following elements.

The handles assure the user with unmatched strength, durability, and comfortable grip owing to its ergonomically smart engineering with triple rivets that sets the tang firm. It is an all-in-one set that meets various professional and home cook needs arising with chopping down the food items in the kitchen.

2.Farberware 18-Piece Forged Stainless Steel Knife Set with Built-in Edgekeeper

  • 8-inch chef knife,
  • 8-inch slicing knife,
  • 8-inch bread knife,
  • 6-inch cleaver,
  • 6-inch chef knife,
  • 6-inch boning knife,
  • 5.5-inch serrated utility knife,
  • 5-inch Santoku knife,
  • 3.5-inch paring knife
  • 3-inch bird-beak paring knife,
  • (6) 4.5-inch steak knives,
  • One pair of all-purpose kitchen shears
  • Natural wood block with sharpeners
  • The woodblock matches most kitchen decor
  • Built-in sharpener to make edge retention simpler
  • Solid and durable from blades to handles
  • Ergonomic handles
  • Handles and blades are prone to tarnishing if not corrosion
  • Some customers reported against the Knives breaking easily
  • A bit costlier

Here’s a set of knives that cuts past the conventional designs of those black synthetic handles into featuring a brush-finished style. Each of the 18 tools in the Farberware Forged Stainless Steel Knife Set is elegant and eye-catching, be it the variety of knives or the natural wood block with a built-in Edgekeeper.

As we did cast a light on, the handles of the knives are made of stainless steel. They are hollow and sleek handles that are highly durable and strong. But there is also a downside to it you may find the grip uncomfortable in the beginning despite the ergonomic design. However, it gets comfortable with time. If you are someone who has had a bad time mastering brush-finished handles, be critically selective here.

3. Farberware 18-Piece Never Needs Sharpening Knife Block Set

  • 8-inch chef knife,
  • 8-inch slicer,
  • 7.5-inch bread knife,
  • 6-inch boning knife,
  • 5-inch utility knife,
  • 4-inch vegetable knife,
  • 4-inch tomato knife,
  • 3-inch cheese knife,
  • 3-inch parer,
  • (6) steak knives
  • One air of kitchen scissors
  • Natural finish wood storage block
  • Sharp, durable, and strong stainless steel blades
  • Textured, non-slip handles for a sure grip
  • Great for regular kitchen as well as for newbie cooks
  • Affordable set
  • Knives are not as sharp as not needing further honing
  • The serrated Chef knife is not impressive
  • Thin enough to operate through starchy vegetables like potatoes

This series is relatively affordable than the 18-piece set we discussed right above. The range of knives in the ‘Never Needs Sharpening’ set is vividly fascinating. From peeling the vegetables for prepping to cutting the steak for eating, the set gets your extensive requirements in the kitchen and dining covered. The tools have superior sharpness for precision, making them the best ones for those getting started with their culinary journeys.

What further adds to making it best for newbies are the stronger grips facilitated by the ergonomic handles. Micro serrations on the blades make cutting and dicing extremely easy to execute and provide precise results. Also, did you notice the names attributed to each knife as a vegetable knife, cheese knife, tomato knife, etc., instead of Santoku, serrated paring, and other complicated names that can be confusing to newbies? This makes it easy to allocate according to the food types and needs for cutting in the kitchen.

4. Farberware Stamped 15-Piece High-Carbon Stainless Steel Knife Block Set

  • 8-inch Chef Knife,
  • 6-inch Bread Knife,
  • 6-inch Slicing Knife,
  • 5-inch Serrated Utility Knife,
  • 4.5-inch Santoku Knife,
  • 3-inch Paring Knife,
  • (6) 4.5-Inch Steak Knives,
  • One all-purpose Kitchen Shear, S
  • Sharpening Steel,
  • Black Wood Block
  • Budget-friendly set with beautiful knives
  • Sturdy and durable from blades to handles
  • Great for beginners as well as regular chefs
  • Satin finish handles with ergonomic shape
  • Balanced, sharped, and lightweight knives.
  • Rust or Tarnish easily
  • No in-built sharpener in the block
  • A few customers have noted minor construction flaws like bubbled plastic

If you want a set of fashionable knives that fit your budget brackets, welcome to the review of the Farberware Stamped Knife Block Set, which has 15 tools comprising 12 varieties of High-Carbon Stainless Steel knives. The handles are aesthetically appealing as they are made of stainless steel that is brushed and given a satin finish. It is a perfect knife set for the ones navigating their way and styles in the kitchen landscape.

It is an excellent set to go with any kitchen decor, a lot of the appeal being credited to the match between stainless steel handles held up in the black storage block. The weight of each knife is well-distributed to add the necessary balance to agile movements. But what may worry you is your comfort with the polished handles- if you are unsure about handling it or maintaining the stainless handles well, be selective before buying.

5. Farberware Stamped Triple Rivet Stainless Steel Kitchen Cleaver

  • Heavy-duty and durable butcher weight
  • Tapered to an extremely sharp fine edge
  • Full tang, ergonomic design with three rivets
  • Resilient soft steel and thick blade

There are endless benefits of owning a butcher knife if you prepare the meat slices at home to get the desired curry cut or buffet pieces. Also known as Kitchen Cleaver, the butcher knives reflect their excellence through three things that we shall lay down to test the kitchen leaver by Farberware. Firstly, the balance of weight makes each stroke of the knife impactful enough to split the ribs, joints, and hard bones of meat and poultry. With the cleaver offered by Farberware, you would experience a greater impact at work with perfect balance to help you get through the cutting task safely.

Secondly, the cleaver’s edge withstands the repeated and sharp blows into the thick meat and bones directly. Farberware offers a dense and tough edge that is reliable and resilient. The blades are tapered to go from fine sharpness to cleaving thickness in matters of millimeters. This allows faster cutting and better precision every time.

Thirdly, the ease of use. It is where Farberware halters a bit. The lack of a rounded angle between handle and blade makes hours of cutting a taxing task to undertake.

6. Farberware Pro 5-Inch Forged Santoku Knife

  • Durable high carbon stainless steel
  • Ergonomic handle with three rivets
  • Ultra-sharp edge
  • Professional series knife with top features.
  • Better edge retention and durability

The professionally forged individual knives by Farberware are one of the best cutleries offered by Farberware. The stainless steel blade is secured in a full tang to the ergonomic handle using three rivets, giving maximum control and firmness. Moreover, the durability is worth the money! Coming down to the Pro 5-Inch Forged Santoku Knife, there are three key areas to consider the quality of the tool based on design, ease of use, and performance.

Based on the design, each knife in the professional series is crafted out of high-carbon stainless steel blades forged into ergonomic handles. They have impeccable and premium edge retention that tends to last ages more than regular knives do. The Santoku knife brings the best attributes of a chef’s knife, cleaver, and a heavy blade together. This brings us to the second parameter that is the ease of use. The knife performs all the heavy-duty tasks of slicing, dicing, and chopping. Thirdly, the extra durability and longevity make the knife an ideal tool to partner your culinary skills. Overall, the knife is performance-oriented, but there could be some severe downsides to it if you do not care for the knife enough.

7. Farberware 4-Piece Full-Tang Knife Set

  • Ergonomic handle
  • Improved easiness in slicing past the steaks
  • Agile and controllable
  • Clean and conventional blades

This set by Farberware offers four steak knives of 4. 5 inches blade each. They belong to the Never Need Sharpening range, which gives it an advantage of precision. The steak knives are our dining table accomplices that help in cutting the flesh out in a steak. With improved ease in getting the steaks cut, one would definitely experience enhanced convenience in dining. If you have guests or relatives over a meal, it is always advisable to put your best foot forward in hosting. Steak knives are generally made of sturdy yet agile knives which have well-distributed weight. Judging by the category, these steak knives get the job done.

These steak knives are not only performative but also very attractive to look at. What further adds to the novelty of the knives is the clean and conventional look that does give a hygienic experience on the table. Besides the appearance, it also offers a decent handling experience with an ergonomic shape. Furthermore, the handles do an exceptional job in adding balance and comfort. Facilitating a comfortable grip, the knives are pretty lightweight to handle and manage. The knives have superior sharpness for precision. Moreover, strength and durability are on point, with the full tang being carved of high-carbon stainless steel.

Sharpener designs

1) Sharpening rods. Two rods, either ceramic or coated with diamond dust, are set in a holder usually at 20˚, 25˚, or 30˚. The rods are used by sliding your knife from top to bottom while pulling or pushing along the entire length of the blade and keeping the blade against the rods. This method is easy to learn and a good way to keep relatively sharp knives sharp. Sharpening rods are fairly inexpensive and can often sharpen serrated knives. They are not useful for sharpening a dull knife.

2) V-sharpeners a.k.a. Pull through sharpeners. These are two hardened pieces of tungsten carbide in a hand-held or table-top device in a V-shape. The knife blade is pulled through the V’s several times to sharpen. They are small and easy to keep in a kitchen drawer, can be used to very quickly sharpen blades, can remove small nicks, and are inexpensive. They are, however, inconsistent, as one pull can be too strong and remove too much metal, while a weaker pull does nothing for the other side of the blade. Sometimes the carbide can catch on nicks on the blade, making them worse.

3) Electric sharpeners. Countertop electric sharpeners get the job done quite nicely and much faster than any hand operated sharpening device. They can be moderately to very expensive but do the trick efficiently. Once your blades have been sharpened, you need to use an electric sharpener only once or twice a month to maintain a fine and sharp edge. Most models have either two or three slots, similar to the V-sharpeners, with discs designed for a range of sharpening from rough to very fine. If improperly used, electric sharpeners can wear down a blade rather quickly though, so use caution and moderation with them.

4) Sharpening stone kits. Many experts consider stones to be the best material for sharpening knives. They are also, by far, the most time-consuming to use. A sharpening stone kit typically comes with several flat stones of different coarseness. You start with the roughest and progress to the smoothest. Each stone is lubricated with water or mineral oil. Pick one, you can’t use both.

Water stones need to be soaked in water for at least an hour. With oil stones, you can drizzle oil on the stone just before you begin the sharpening process. Use only mineral oils. Vegetable oils can harden, clog, and ruin a sharpening stone. If you’ve got free time, and don’t mind a repetitive, and somewhat tedious process, have at it.

We are not reviewing sharpening stones at this time. Instead, we will conduct a much more detailed review and test of the best among the huge variety of stones available. We’ll also review the best and worst methods of using sharpening stones.

5) Sharpening steels. These are not sharpeners. Steels cannot remove nicks or sharpen dull blades, and they don’t remove any steel. Instead, they realign the rolled metal edges of knife blade into a straight line, which makes the blade cut better. They are very common and can be used daily to slightly improve a blade’s performance. Steels are easier to use than real knife sharpeners and they are inexpensive. There are three kinds: smooth, ridged, and diamond coated. Because they do not actually sharpen, we did not test any steels at this time. But we do recommend keeping a steel on hand to keep your knife cutting at its best. Here is a link to one we recommend.

6) Strops. A strop is a flat piece of leather, often attached to a thin strip of wood. They have a little flexibility or bend and are used in a similar fashion to steels. However, they are even less effective at sharpening, merely realigning the edges of knives. We did not test any strops, but they are another decent option for honing a knife between uses. We prefer steels.

How to to Get the Best Out of Your Knives at Home

Welcome to Out of the Kitchen , our ongoing exploration of America’s coolest food artisans. Over the next few months, we’re apprenticing with the best knife forgers, cider brewers, and spice blenders, then bringing their knowledge and expertise back to our home kitchens—and to yours.

Christmas came in September for me this year.

When I heard I was going to the Bloodroot Blades shop with staff writer Rochelle Bilow in Georgia to learn knife making from to start to finish with Bloodroot owners David Van Wyk and Luke Snyder , I was, to put it mildly, stoked. You see, I’ve always had a passion for knives, and this spring I started making my own kitchen knives from old carbon-steel blanks I buy from an old French chef. (It’s a long story.)

For me, shaping and sharpening knives is the perfect mix of a day of metal and woodwork, and seriously scratches my lifelong itch to make something with my own two hands—be it squid-and-veggie ramen or the fiberglass finish on a surfboard. And knife making is as much art as science, as far as I’m concerned: Forging metals from an old farm tool into a blade thin enough to effortlessly cut a tomato yet strong enough to mince ginger, all while looking beautiful, is comparable to Ginger Rogers dancing backwards in heels. Getting to go to Bloodroot Blades was like watching magic being made, and I left Georgia with a new appreciation for knives—and new ideas about how to buy and care for them.

But even the most devoted home cooks aren’t going to be making knives in their backyards (and probably shouldn’t). Still, everyone should know how to buy knives and to care for them. Like I said, even for a professional like me (you'll find me in the Bon Appétit test kitchen Monday through Friday), the trip to Bloodroot changed the way I think about my own blades, both the ones I make and the ones I purchase ( read more about Van Wyk, Snyder and Bloodroot here ) . Getting my hands dirty and learning how knives come into being at the hands of these artisans left me with greater insight into the knives I buy and care for—here's how you can be a master knife owner, too.

Leone, forging metal at the Bloodroot workshop. Photo: Paige French

The Bloodroot Credo: The Right Knife for the Job

Buying knives can be an intimidating experience. They come in all different shapes and sizes, all of which do certain jobs—you wouldn’t want to use a slicer to core a tomato. It’s worth doing some research on the knife you’re interested in to make sure it's the right tool for what you have in mind. The Bloodroot guys reminded me how important it is to remember that.

Most chefs only use and need a handful of knives—even if they own 25, they usually grab the same four or five. "Buy fewer knives, and buy better knives," says Snyder. There are a few staples everyone should own: a three-to-five-inch paring or petty knife, a ten-inch slicer, a seven-to-eight-inch chef’s knife, and the wild card—a boning or fillet knife. (My steadies are my five-inch petty knife, razor-sharp Chinese cleaver, ten-inch slicer, and fillet and boning knives.) The Bloodroot guys’ best seller is their Japanese-style gyuto , which is basically an eight-inch chef’s knife. Granted, admits Van Wyk, "If you love breaking down whole chickens and get a lot of joy in that, buy a cleaver." But for the most part, the basics will get the job done. If you love to cook, then it’s worth buying the tools to get the job done correctly. You’ll thank yourself later.

Heavy Metal

Knowing what kind of metal your knife is made of is a key decision in buying , because it will affect the way it must be treated. If it’s a knife that’s high in carbon steel, then you need to wash and dry it thoroughly after each use. Leaving water on carbon steel will leave rust spots (which you shouldn’t confuse with patina, which is the normal chemical reaction carbon steel will undergo over time). On the other hand, stainless-steel knives won’t rust or show discoloration—but they also can’t get as razor-sharp or maintain an edge as long as carbon-steel knives. Ultimately though, says Snyder, "You can geek out about steel types, but a knife's longevity is all about how you sharpen it, what you cut on, and how you treat it."

Online Is Fine, but In-Person Is Certain

There’s nothing wrong with buying a knife online—if you’re familiar with the style and maker. Otherwise, go to a store with a large knife selection that will allow you to hold and feel the knives. Once you pick it up, you'll know pretty quickly whether or not the knife is a match for you. Van Wyk and Snyder imparted to me an appreciation for custom-made knives made by artisans, of course, but if you can’t find one of those, there’s nothing wrong with going to Williams-Sonoma or a store with a decent knife shop. Just because you're not getting a custom-made knife made specifically for you doesn't mean that you can't still find the perfect knife for what you have in mind.

Remember the first point—use the right knife for the job. Know what you want to do with the knife and keep that in mind when purchasing. Don’t be shy about asking questions. Let someone help you find the tool that best suits you.

Balancing Act

My time at Bloodroot taught me about the importance of balance. Balancing the knife allows the blade—and its cutting motion—to work with you and not against you, which could ultimately fatigue your hand and wrist. The balance of the knife should be right around the bolster (the knob or metal band where the blade meets the handle), and you should be able to hold up and balance the whole knife evenly on a single finger at that one point.

But at the same time, the balance of the knife also depends on where you hold your knife —and everyone tends to hold a knife a little differently. If you’re lucky enough to have a custom blade made for you, talk to your knifemaker about your unique needs (Are you slicing fish filets from the bones, or whacking a chicken in half?), so that you'll get the best possible tool.

Van Wyk finishes a custom knife. Photo: Paige French

Respect Your Blades

The guys of Bloodroot respect their blades and so should you, no matter where you get your knives—or what kind they are. Someone who respects his or her blade remembers: No knife should be left dirty on the cutting board or thrown into a drawer with 20 other kitchen tools and knives. Clean your knife and put it away immediately after use.

In my kitchen, the rule is: As soon as you’re done with a knife, it gets hand-washed, dried, and put back on the magnetic strip. (When it comes to storing your knives, Bloodroot suggests using a magnetic knife strip that gets hung on the wall in your kitchen. It makes it easy to find the knife you need, and prevents damage to the blade, ultimately keeping your knife sharper and longer-lasting.)

No knife should be left in the bottom of a sink—whether it’s carbon or stainless—ever! Don’t put knives in a dishwasher, as it can affect the metal and damage the handles, which can ultimately end in total knife failure.

"Just pay attention to the knife," Van Wyk says. "It's not a spoon."

Lookin’ Sharp!

You will need a honing steel and sharpening whetstones if you’re serious about your knives.

Also, maintaining your edge by using a ceramic hone—a rod used to straighten out microscopic nicks—will keep the edge sharp and require you to make fewer trips to the stone. If you’re handling the knife properly as you sharpen, you should only hit the stone two or three times a year, max, on any well-made knife. Honing steels come in various materials, but what really matters is that you use a material that’s harder than your knife. Bloodroot likes Mac ceramic honers —they’re $25 and real workhorses.

Hone your knife's edge regularly by running it down the steel on the same angle that it’s sharpened at. When honing, you are correcting the edge—imagine the cross-section of a dulled blade where the edge is rolled over to one side, like the curl of a wave seen from the side. By honing it, you are simply straightening the edge until it becomes a sharpened triangle.

Sharpening is another process entirely. Whereas honing is simply straightening out the tiny divots in your knife, sharpening means you're essentially filing down a the edge of a dull knife, actually shaving away metal against a whetstone until you get a keen edge.

Van Wyk and Snyder say there’s no one way to sharpen a knife. It’s really about consistency and evenness. That means you don’t need to go fast, and you don’t need to sharpen for 50 minutes—unless you are fixing a damaged knife, a few passes on each side is fine. ____

Don't try this at home: Snyder tests a blade's sharpness by slicing off his arm hair. Photo: Paige French

Van Wyk and Snyder say synthetic whetstones with a grit of 1,000 to 1,200 are great for most uses—go for a 6,000 rating for fine polishing and finishing. (The stones are measured the same way sandpaper is labeled, 60 being really coarse and 6,000 being super fine.)

When putting blade to whetstone, you want to follow the angle that your edge was created with. There isn’t one correct way to sharpen on a whetstone—it’s an art form unto itself. Just find a method you’re comfortable with and that gives you results, take your time, and be consistent. Consider asking a professional to show you their technique first. I recommend practicing on an inexpensive knife. When you’ve got it down, move on to your “real” knives. There’s nothing more satisfying then putting an even, razor-sharp edge on a knife.

If you want to go to the extra mile, you can use a leather strop to give the knife a nice polish. If you don’t have a leather strop, you can just use newspaper on a hard surface —run the knife along the length of the paper at the same angle you would to sharpen it, pulling the knife away from the edge. “It’s free, and it works,” Snyder says.

Where to Cut

A common mistake is using the wrong type of cutting board. You don’t want to cut on a surface that’s harder then your knife. This will cause the edge to roll and become dull and even damaged. Don’t cut on your granite countertop—and, please, if you have a glass cutting board, throw it away and pretend that chapter in your life never happened. Super hard g____lass is one of the worst materials you can use to chop on.

An end-grain wooden cutting board is ideal, but any hardwood board is good. Snyder says to stay away from plastic as your "everyday" board because cuts in the surface will harbor bacteria. Bamboo will dull your blade because of its fibrous makeup. A more traditional hardwood is softer then metal and will keep your knife sharp and provide a better cutting surface. The end grain receives the blade, and minor cuts in the surface of an end-grain board will seal up, keeping the cutting surface clean. A quality wood cutting board should last you plenty of years.

Weekend in the Country

Spending a weekend down at Bloodroot's headquarters, making knives and getting to know Van Wyk and Snyder really opened my eyes up to how much I can still learn. Having the right tools to do any job—whether it be forging knives or cooking chicken soup—makes all the difference in your finished product. But tools alone will only take you so far putting in the work and learning the art is what separates quality from everything else, and that's what makes Bloodroot Blades so special.

The next time I buy a knife for myself (likely a three-inch boning knife), I'm going to mentally relive the weekend at Bloodroot: I'm going to test out the balance so that it's weighted a bit more toward the front, suiting my holding style. I'm going to let the seller know that I'll be using it to take apart everything from goats to delicate fish. I'm going to ask for carbon steel, because I like the way the material holds an edge, and I love the patina it develops over use and time like a badge of honor. And when I get it home, I'm going to take care of it—no dishwasher for my new baby.

Because Bloodroot reminded me that, for someone who cooks, a knife is more than a tool, it's an extension of your hand, the farthest point of your body, changing this world into another one that your mind imagines. Watching them work reminded me that there's nothing as satisfying as cutting a soft tomato with a sharp knife and feeling it fall right through the flesh, or cutting a steak off the bone and leaving no tear, no ragged edges, just a perfect steak. It's like a driving a Ferrari—you don't want to go back to a Toyota Corolla. A knife is a piece of art, but it's functional. And watching Snyder and Van Wyk create the Ferraris of the knife world reinforced in me how important every step along the way is, from heating the metal in the oven to pounding it with a hammer to finding the right use and owner for it to wiping it down after every use. And if I continue to treat my most treasured knives right? Someday I may get to pass them on to my kid.

Or as, the Bloodroot guys like to say, from the Bloodroot forge to my cutting board, each knife is its own story, and I get to tell the final chapter.

But the most important thing I took away from Bloodroot was a sense of possibility: Their shop made me want to leave New York City and buy an old farm to build a workshop on.

Watch the video: Snick-X Tomato slicing test (July 2022).


  1. Ames

    I think you admit the mistake. I propose to examine.

  2. Magnus

    I accidentally found this forum today and specially registered to participate in the discussion.

  3. JoJoll

    his phrase is magnificent

  4. Tekazahn

    I apologize, but in my opinion you admit the mistake. Write to me in PM, we will discuss.

  5. JoJorn

    Bravo, what necessary phrase..., a remarkable idea

  6. Laius

    I am sure about that.

  7. Doulkree

    I consider, that you are not right. I am assured. I suggest it to discuss. Write to me in PM, we will communicate.

Write a message